Barney Greengrass Menu (2025 Update)
Introducing Barney Greengrass, a cherished New York City institution located at 541 Amsterdam Avenue. This renowned eatery has delighted patrons for over a century with its exceptional menu, celebrating the art of smoked fish and traditional Jewish deli fare.
Highlights include the Smoked Fish Platters, featuring Nova Scotia Salmon and Sturgeon, that promise a burst of flavor for $65. For a grand culinary experience, the Premium Deluxe Platter served with bagels is a must-try at $169, showcasing the best of Barney Greengrass's offerings.
Don’t miss their hot egg sandwiches, a unique take on classic combinations like Pastrami Salmon and Egg. Customers rave about the charming, albeit cramped, ambiance—it's a quintessential NYC experience. With fast and friendly service, this deli not only serves great food but also fosters a warm communal vibe. Bring cash, embrace the hustle, and enjoy a piece of culinary history at Barney Greengrass.
Desserts Sides Herrings Caviar Specialties Sandwiches - Sandwich Specialties Sandwiches - Hot Egg Sandwiches Sandwiches - Cheese Sandwiches Sandwiches - Meat Sandwiches Sandwiches - Triple Deckers Appetizers Eggs, Omelettes, and Dairy - Eggs & Omelettes Eggs, Omelettes, and Dairy - Dairy Suggestions Smoked Fish Platters
Desserts
Rugelach
US$8.00
Chocolate Babka Muffin
US$6.00
New York Cheesecake
US$8.50
Danish
US$5.50
Large Black and White Cookie
US$6.00
Mini Black and White Cookies
(4 pieces)
US$9.00
Rice Pudding
US$7.00
Chocolate Covered Halvah Bar with Nuts
US$4.00
Chocolate Layered Halvah
US$9.00
Marble
US$9.00
Marble Nut Halvah
US$9.00
Large Loaf of Chocolate Babka
US$17.50
Seasonal Fruit
P/A
Cream Cheese
US$3.50
Vegetable Cream Cheese
US$4.50
Scallion Cream Cheese
US$4.50
Lox Cream Cheese Spread
US$7.00
Lite (Low Fat) Cream Cheese
US$4.00
Tofu (Non-Dairy) Cream Cheese
US$4.00
Farmer Cheese
US$7.00
Horseradish Cheddar Cheese with Flat Bread Crackers
US$12.50
Creamy French Brie
US$11.50
Imported Swiss Cheese
US$9.50
Muenster Cheese
US$8.00
Sweet Munchee Cheese
US$9.00
Manchego Cheese
US$15.00
Midnight Moon Cheese
US$18.00
Sour Cream
US$4.50
Pickled Onions and Cream Sauce
US$7.50
Lettuce and Tomato
US$9.75
Side of Sliced Tomato
US$6.00
Imported Preserve
US$1.50
Imported Honey
US$1.50
Cole Slaw
US$4.50
Potato Salad
US$4.50
Cucumber Salad
US$6.00
Green Stuffed Olives
US$6.00
Greek Olives
(Moslinas)
US$6.00
Capers
US$2.50
Pickle
US$4.00
Pickled Tomato
US$4.00
Red Peppers
US$5.00
Stewed Prunes
US$6.00
Potato, Kasha
US$7.50
Spinach Knish
US$7.50
Noodle Pudding
US$8.50
Flat Bread Crackers
US$9.00
Pletzel
(Large Bialy Wheel)
US$7.00
Assorted Pickle Plate
US$10.00
Sides
Herrings
Pickled Herring in Cream Sauce
US$16.50
Home Made Chopped Herring
US$15.50
Fillet of Matjes Herring
US$15.50
Fillet of Schmaltz Herring
(Very Salty)
US$15.50
Broiled Imported Kippers and Onions
US$17.50
Fresh Malosol Osetra Caviar with Chopped Eggs and Onions
US$249.00
American Caviar with Chopped Egg and Onion
US$90.00
Caviar Sampler
US$180.00
Red Salmon Caviar with Sour Cream
US$23.00
Caviar
Specialties
Nova Scotia Salmon Scrambled with Eggs and Onions
US$21.00
Sturgeon Scrambled with Eggs and Onions
US$24.00
Combination of Sturgeon and Nova Scotia Salmon Scrambled with Eggs and Onions
US$26.00
Lox (Salty) Scrambled with Eggs and Onions
US$21.00
Pastrami Salmon Scrambled with Eggs and Onions
US$21.00
Nova Scotia Heads and Wings Broiled with Onions
US$20.00
Sturgeon
US$25.00
Nova Scotia Salmon
US$21.00
Sturgeon and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$27.50
Nova Scotia Salmon with Swiss Cheese
US$23.00
Lox
(Salty)
US$21.00
Kippered (Baked) Salmon
US$21.00
Kippered (Baked) Salmon and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$24.00
Pastrami Salmon
US$21.00
House Cured Gravlox
US$21.00
Whitefish
US$21.00
Whitefish and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$23.00
Home Made Whitefish Salad
US$17.00
Home Made Kippered Salmon Salad
US$18.50
Sable
US$25.00
Sable and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$27.50
Sturgeon and Sable
US$30.00
Solid White Tuna Fish
US$15.00
Home Made Chopped Herring
US$15.50
Imported Sardines
US$14.50
Home Made Egg Salad
US$13.50
Sandwiches - Sandwich Specialties
Sandwiches - Hot Egg Sandwiches
Sturgeon and Egg
US$19.25
Nova Scotia Salmon and Egg
US$17.00
Combination of Sturgeon and Nova Scotia Salmon and Egg
US$21.50
Pastrami Salmon and Egg
US$17.00
Corned Beef and Egg
US$15.50
Tongue and Egg
US$17.75
Pastrami and Egg
US$15.50
Salami and Egg
US$15.50
Cream Cheese
US$6.00
Cream Cheese and Jelly
US$7.50
Vegetable Cream Cheese
US$7.00
Scallion Cream Cheese
US$7.00
Lox Cream Cheese Spread
US$8.00
Lite (Low Fat) Cream Cheese
US$6.50
Farmer Cheese
US$8.00
Horseradish Cheddar Cheese
US$8.00
Imported Swiss Cheese
US$9.00
Jarlsberg Cheese
US$9.00
Sweet Munchee Cheese
US$9.00
American
US$8.00
Muenster Cheese
US$8.00
Bagel and Butter
US$5.00
Rye
US$5.00
Pumpernickel Bread with Butter
US$5.00
Sandwiches - Cheese Sandwiches
Sandwiches - Meat Sandwiches
Hot Pastrami
US$19.75
Pastrami Reuben
US$24.00
Corned Beef
US$19.75
Smoked Turkey
US$18.00
Roast Beef
US$19.75
Tongue
US$22.00
Salami
US$18.00
Chopped Chicken Liver
US$16.00
Corned Beef, Chopped Liver, Sliced Onion
US$23.00
Pastrami, Salami, Tongue, Cole Slaw and Russian Dressing
US$26.00
Sturgeon, Nova Scotia Salmon, Cream Cheese, Onion and Tomato
US$29.50
Tongue, Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Cole Slaw and Russian Dressing
US$26.00
Roast Beef, Chicken Liver, Turkey, Cole Slaw and Russian Dressing
US$25.00
Corned Beef, Tongue, Swiss Cheese, Cole Slaw and Russian Dressing
US$26.00
Turkey, Pastrami, Cole Slaw and Russian Dressing
US$24.00
Turkey, Chopped Liver, Tomato, Cole Slaw and Russian Dressing
US$24.00
Corned Beef, Pastrami, Cole Slaw and Russian Dressing
US$25.00
Sandwiches - Triple Deckers
Appetizers
Sturgeon
US$25.00
Nova Scotia Salmon
US$21.00
Sturgeon and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$27.50
Lox
(Salty)
US$21.00
Pickled Lox in Cream Sauce
US$24.00
Kippered (Baked) Salmon
US$22.00
Kippered (Baked) Salmon and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$24.00
Pastrami Salmon
US$21.00
House Cured Gravlox
US$21.00
Whitefish
US$21.00
Whitefish and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$23.50
Home Made Whitefish Salad
US$20.00
Home Made Kippered Salmon Salad
US$21.00
Whitefish Salad and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$23.50
Sable
US$25.00
Sable and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$27.50
Sturgeon and Sable
US$30.00
Smoked Rainbow Trout
US$16.00
Nova Scotia Heads and Wings Broiled with Onions
US$16.00
Ventresca Tuna Fillets
US$28.00
Home Made Solid White Tuna Salad
US$16.00
Imported Sardines
US$14.50
Egg Salad
US$14.50
Home Made Chopped Chicken Liver
US$17.00
Gefilte Fish with Horseradish
US$15.50
Eggs with side of Sturgeon
US$25.00
Eggs with side of Nova Scotia Salmon
US$21.00
Eggs with side of Sturgeon and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$27.50
Eggs with side of Lox
(Salty)
US$21.00
Eggs with side of Kippered (Baked) Salmon
US$22.00
Eggs with side of Pastrami Salmon
US$21.00
Eggs with side of House Cured Gravlox
US$21.00
Eggs with side of Whitefish
US$21.00
Whitefish Salad
US$21.00
Eggs with side of Whitefish and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$23.50
Eggs with side of Sable
US$25.00
Eggs with side of Sable and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$27.50
Eggs with side of Broiled Imported Kippers and Onions
US$19.00
Corned Beef
US$19.00
Pastrami Omelette
US$19.00
Tongue Omelette
US$21.00
Pastrami Omelette with Swiss Cheese
US$22.50
Salami Omelette
US$19.00
Mushroom Omelette
US$15.00
Two Eggs Any Style
US$10.50
Onions and Eggs
US$15.00
Onion Omelette
US$15.00
Eggs, Omelettes, and Dairy - Eggs & Omelettes
Eggs, Omelettes, and Dairy - Dairy Suggestions
Challah French Toast
US$14.50
Sturgeon
US$51.00
Nova Scotia Salmon
US$43.00
Sturgeon and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$56.00
Whitefish
US$43.00
Whitefish Salad Platter.
US$43.00
Extra Large Whitefish Portion
US$49.00
Sturgeon, Nova Scotia Salmon and Whitefish
US$65.00
Nova Scotia Salmon and Whitefish
US$47.00
Nova Scotia Salmon and Sable
US$56.00
Sturgeon and Sable
US$60.00
Nova Scotia Salmon and Whitefish Salad
US$47.00
Lox
(Salty)
US$43.00
Kippered (Baked) Salmon
US$43.00
Kippered (Baked) Salmon and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$48.00
Pastrami Salmon
US$43.00
House Cured Gravlox
US$43.00
Sable
US$51.00
Kippered Salmon, Sable and Lox
(Salty)
US$65.00
Kippered Salmon, Sable and Nova Scotia Salmon
US$65.00
Nova Scotia Salmon, Sable and Whitefish
US$65.00
Nova Scotia Salmon, Sturgeon and Kippered Salmon
US$65.00
Nova Scotia Salmon, Sturgeon, and Sable
Platters served with Potato Salad or Cole Slaw, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Olives, Pickle, Lemon, Plain Cream Cheese and two Bagels or two Bialys.
US$72.00
Deluxe Platter for 2:
Sturgeon, Nova Scotia Salmon, Kippered Salmon, Sable and Whitefish
US$129.00
Premium Deluxe Platter:
Deluxe Platters served with three Bagels or three Bialys Sturgeon, Nova Scotia Salmon, Pastrami Salmon, Gravlox, Kippered Salmon, Sable and Whitefish
US$169.00